Which Is Better, Direct or Indirect Trading?
February 18th, 2007 · by Bob Meyer · 4 CommentsBy Bob Meyer
I’m often asked which is the better way to trade. Going out and doing a direct, 1:1 trade or joining a trade exchange and then trading on an indirect basis, i.e. moving your products or services for trade dollars first, and subsequently using them to acquire the product or service needed.
Once a specific situation is known, the answer to the question can quickly be answered. But generally, and for a variety of reasons, using a currency (trade dollar) for your trading purposes has several advantages. Here are eleven reasons to consider.
• The convenience of finding responsive trading partners through the trade exchange directory that lists members.
• Ease of trading through the use of a common currency, i.e. trade dollars.
• An immense variety of goods and services available through a trade exchange, versus that of trading on a direct basis.
• Obtaining the exact products and services wanted in the desired amount.
• Greater assurance of the trade being completed, since trade dollars can be spent anywhere at any time within the exchange. (In direct trades if the entire trade isn’t transacted immediately, one must rely upon the trading partner delivering at a later date. Which means that you’re dependent upon your trading partner’s honesty and solvency.)
• Promotional costs that bring you added business are handled by the exchange.
• Collection and bad debts costs are eliminated, as all barter sales need an authorization.
• You never extend credit to the buyer (there are no receivables). Any credit extended to members is done through the trade exchange office.
• New cash business can often be obtained through referrals from satisfied trade members, who primarily are the owners or managers of their company.
• Loans (credit lines) acquired through the exchange are normally paid back in trade dollars, and interest on the trade dollar loan is paid with trade dollars, too. (Some trade exchanges extend loans to credit-worthy members, at no interest.) Your only cash costs when borrowing trade dollars is the usual cash service fee when you use their services.
• Regional and national trading opportunities, through the exchange’s intercity trading contacts.
This entry was posted on Sunday, February 18th, 2007 at 8:42 am and is filed under Entrepreneurs & Small Business, Best & Brightest Barter. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

February 20th, 2007 at 12:53 pm
Bob:
I agree with you in that a company in the process of exploring barter should consider trading through an organized barter group.
My company has traded for 25 years and the majority of barter we do is indirect trading. But we always keep our eyes open for additional business through direct trades. I have even taken an inventory I acquired in a direct trade and sold it for trade dollars.
February 21st, 2007 at 7:54 pm
Thanks for the comment Carl. It’s been several years since we’ve had a chance to talk face-to-face. Looking forward to some more conversations when I get up your way.
June 21st, 2007 at 8:57 pm
I think it all depends on the situation.
If you find someone to do a direct trade with whom you benefit as much as they do with you then a direct trade will work just fine. In most cases though the direct trade doesn’t work because it doesn’t benefit both sides the same way.
Through a trade exchange, it benefits both sides the same way because you use trade dollars just like you would cash. So in my opinion if you find that perfect trade then that is the best way to go (maybe 1% of the time that will happpen), otherwise through a trade exchange just makes good business sense.
Chris Benton
July 1st, 2007 at 7:20 pm
The Barter Industry has more in-fighting than modern-day religion. We spend most of our time living in fear, working overtime to herd cats instead of building what we have to be bigger and better.
Direct trade happens when it makes sense to the parties involved OR, if they don’t have an ethical relationship with their barter group.
Trade Exchanges exist because we make barter work better in most cases like the money system makes business better.
We tell our members that a direct trade that makes sense is a great deal as long as it is ethical. If we created the relationship and the deal, we deserve the business and they usually do the right thing.
When they don’t do the right thing, we remind them that they have offended the Barter God and will be punished…